The lack of substantial evidence to support the hearing officer’s findings results in the court annulling the disciplinary action
Meaney v Village of Johnson City, 2012 NY Slip Op 04265, Appellate Division, Third Department
The mayor of the Village of Johnson City demoted a fire captain to firefighter first class after adopting the findings of the disciplinary hearing officer that a fire captain was guilty of multiple counts of misconduct and incompetence.
The Appellate Division annulled the mayor’s determination and reinstated the captain to his former position with back salary.
In explaining its ruling the Appellate Division said:
1. Substantial evidence does not support the determination of guilt;
2. The disciplinary charges were based on the captain’s “failure to disclose information that was neither solicited nor relevant to the conversation” with a police detective and “under no reasonable view of the evidence can it be said that the captain’s silence was willful or indicative of ‘some dereliction or neglect of duty’ on his part;” and
3. The captain was not charged with making inaccurate statements to his superior and, thus, cannot be disciplined for allegedly making such statements.
The decision is posted on the Internet at:
http://www.courts.state.ny.us/reporter/3dseries/2012/2012_04265.htm